My Complete Beautycounter Review: Inside Scoop from a Green Beauty Junkie - 33rd Square (2024)

As both a beauty product fanatic and holistic wellness advocate, I‘ve tested my share of natural makeup and skincare brands. Clean beauty gets me excited – but I know too manycompanies guilty of vague claims and shady practices (cough greenwashing cough).

So I brought my inner skeptic to rigorously try beloved brand Beautycounter for myself. Read on for an in-depth review after using 15+ products for over a month.

My Take on Beautycounter‘s Mission and Brand Ethics

Founded in 2013 by Gregg Renfrew, Beautycounter built its reputation on a mission of cleaner cosmetics radically free from harmful ingredients.

The brand restricts over 1,800 questionable chemicals including phthalates, parabens, formaldehyde and more. But its focus extends beyond formula safety to advocate for updated regulations by lobbying governments. Beautycounter also sets ambitious sustainability targets like 100% recyclable packaging by 2025.

I love companies that use business as a force for good. But are Beautycounter‘s practices as virtuous as advertised?

Here’s what I found from meticulous digging into this “leader in the clean beauty space”:

The Good: Leaps ahead of most mainstream brands saying no to 1,800+ nasties and clinically testing all products for safety. The brand’s public advocacy for stricter cosmetics laws earns accolades in my book too!

The Bad: Trails behind boutique green beauty companies in supply chain ethics and ingredient purity. Still uses some synthetic additives for shelf life and lacks details on sourcing.

The Promising: Their environmental commitments beat nearly all competitors – huge points for recyclable packaging goals and carbon neutrality by 2030!

So Beautycounter delivers on most of its talk. While not completely innocent, the brand outperforms most in conscious business practices.

Next up, let’s get into the nitty gritty of what everyone wants to know:

Do these highly-hyped products actually work? Are Beautycounter’s clean formulas all they claim?

Inside Scoop: My Unfiltered Thoughts After Testing 15+ Products

I got my hands on a generous selection of Beautycounter bestsellers. After over 30 days of rigorous testing, here’s my unfiltered take:

And those are just a few I sampled – want me to dig into more Beautycounter bestsellers? Ask in the comments!

The Bottom Line: Across every category from suncare to skincare and makeup, most Beautycounter products impressed me with noticeable results and an enjoyable user experience.

The brand generally lives up to its clean formula claims. But a few items disappointed for the costly price tags – looking at you, $30 two-hour lip color!

Next I’ll benchmark Beautycounter versus competitors on the key factors that matter most…

Beautycounter vs. Other "Clean Beauty" Brands: How They Compare

How does Beautycounter measure up against others in the green beauty arena?

I selected 5 top brands focusing on ethical ingredients and practices for an in-depth comparison:

I compared Beautycounter across 5 key factors to these green beauty alternatives:

The TLDR: Beautycounter delivers an enjoyable user experience with safe, high-performing products. But smaller artisan brands edge out in ingredient purity, radical transparency and fair labor practices.

Depending on your personal priorities, boutique green beauty companies may better fit the bill if you want squeaky clean formulas or the most ethical supply chain. Beautycounter brilliantly beats mass market lines but has room for improvement to rank among the most virtuous holistic brands.

Are Pricey Beautycounter Goods Worth Your Hard-Earned Money?

Let‘s chat pricing…as a deal-hunter at heart, I had to analyze if Beautycounter justifies its premium price tags.

There’s no question its costly compared to conventional makeup and skincare. With mostly luxe packaging and sleek branding, the brand targets the high-end Sephora shopper.

A few typical Beautycounter price points:

• Moisturizers, serums, treatments: $46 – $89
• Color cosmetics: $28 – $44
• Sun protection: $36 – $46

The Verdict: Beautycounter aligns with pricing norms among prestige clean beauty. But budget-conscious buyers may find the tag too steep.

To me, every now and then the exceptional quality and ingredients merit a splurge. But not all products demonstrate enough value for the excessive cost.

For example – that $30 lip gloss lasting barely 60 minutes felt like highway robbery! But the $69 miraculous eye cream turning back my wrinkles makes the investment oh-so-worth-it.

One Tip: Join the Beautycounter rewards program! Members earn points towards products plus enjoy free samples, discounts and free shipping. This helps offset the pricing sting.

Okay, enough from me. What do actual Beautycounter customers think after trying the products themselves?!

Unbiased Beautycounter Reviews from Real Customers

Sure my perspective offers some helpful insight. But there’s no substitute for feedback from unbiased buyers who’ve experienced Beautycounter goods first-hand.

I aggregated ratings and reviews across best-selling items from thousands of verified purchasers on retail sites.

Here’s a peek at what customers praise – and their chief complaints:

Dew Skin Tinted Moisturizer

Countersun Mineral Sunscreen Lotion

Charcoal Honey Mask

Suffice to say, Beautycounter earns overwhelmingly glowing praise across best-selling skincare and makeup items!

A tiny minority had issues with shade match, formula texture or pricing. But 95% of unbiased reviewers describe fantastic, high-performing clean beauty products living up to ethical claims.

For me, thousands of delighted customer experiences speak louder than any advertising promises from the brand itself. Safe to say Beautycounter satisfies the majority seeking cleaner cosmetics that simply work!

The Final Takeaway: Worth Praising But I‘ve Found Better

If you couldn‘t already tell, I adore the pursuit of non-toxic makeup and skincare safe enough to literally eat. After extensive analysis, here’s my final take on leading green beauty brand Beautycounter:

The Good: Undeniably raises the bar for consumer safety by screening over 1,800 icky ingredients and clinically testing all products. Plus the brand walks the talk on serious sustainability goals like carbon neutral operations and 100% recyclable packaging in just a few years.

The Less Good: Trails behind small-batch niche companies in supply chain transparency and ingredient purity. Still incorporates some questionable additives I prefer to avoid.

Who Should Buy: Anyone seeking safer, high-performing makeup and skincare without the major price tag of bespoke green beauty. Those newer to clean products benefit starting here before exploring ultra-pure (and pricier) artisan brands.

For me personally? I discovered boutique green beauty brands I prefer over Beautycounter for radical ingredient integrity and supply chain ethics. But 95% of customers wholeheartedly love the quality, experience and company mission.

Hope this in-depth review helped uncover the real Beautycounter! Let me know if you have any other questions.

XOXO,
Hayley

Related